My two mascara favorites are the Benefit Cosmetics Bad Gal Bang in plum or brown and the drugstore option is the Maybelline Sky High Mascara in burgandy haze. Benefit cosmetic bad gal bang mascara in PLUM: An intense lash that's all volume, no weight? Oh, yeah. With Benefit's BADgal BANG! volumizing mascara, every swipe lays on 360 fullness that lasts 36 hours* without smudging. The plum is best for green and hazel eyes. Brown is best for blue and hazel eyes. LTKBeauty LTKWatchNow LTKFindsUnder50