Probably the best loafers I bought, tried on and tested in 2024:
Flattered Sigrid loafer - so elegant and timeless (if you’re planning to wear them with socks and your feet aren’t super narrow go half a size up otherwise you’ll need to stretch them out a bit)
Madewell x G.H.BASS Lennox Weejuns® Loafers in suede with tassels - obsessed!
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer (use the code WINTER to get 40% off) - for this price they truly are the best of the best.
Gianvito Rossi Women's Harris Moccasin (50% off at Farfetch right now but they’re final sale so if you aren’t quite sure get them on sale at Bloomingdale’s, both options linked)
G.H. Bass WOMENS LIANNA BIT EASY WEEJUN (these are the ones with rubber soles)
Gucci Jordaan loafers (worth the splurge in the long run)
H&M leather loafers (only $100!)
Paul Green Wheaton Flat (I linked them from everywhere but I’d get them from Nordstrom right now, all sizes available and the full price is lower than on the official website!)
LTKSaleAlert LTKSeasonal LTKShoeCrush