All Our Beautiful Goodbyes by Julianne Maclean ⭐⭐⭐💫 Pub Day: March 25, 2025 Pages: 356 Audiobook Length: 11 hours, 14 minutes Bethany's Review: Set in post WWII on a beautiful island in Canada. This was a beautiful sweeping historical fiction romance that follows Emma Clarkson on her journey of falling in love and becoming independent. The descriptions of Sable Island felt like I was right there. It was so interesting reading up on Sable Island after I was done with the story. It was obvious that Maclean put in a ton of research to write this. While I was invested in the characters and I think the character development was outstanding, I wasn’t fully invested in Emma’s love story. It fell flat for me. I don’t think historical fiction romance is my favorite genre. For those of you who enjoy that type of reading, you will love this! Sara's Review: This book was beautifully written. I loved the descriptions of Sable Island. The love, both romantic and family, is so strong and wonderful. It was written in two timelines, which was fine, although I am not sure it really brought anything to the story. I enjoyed that it was a historical fiction, family drama with the main character being a woman who has experienced extreme heartbreak, yet still pushes through. I found it was well written and enjoyable, although parts of the book did drag on a little more than I would have liked. The romance part felt forced and not realistic, but it did not stop me from enjoying the book. Overall, a beautifully written story that will have you reaching for the tissues. Thank you netgalley for my audiobook arc LTKHome LTKSeasonal LTKFindsUnder50