These are all excellent tubing mascaras. One is only available by ordering on the company’s website and these other 2 are drugstore beauty products. I’ve always loved Thrive and stand by it, BUT these others work well. I’m going to say that the Milani would be my pick. No flaking, no transfer and removes easily with just water.
LTKOver40 LTKBeauty LTKFindsUnder50